Tag Archives: Supreme Court

Theek hai, the mask is off…

But tales of Singh’s personal honesty and integrity were always in the domain of the Congress party and the mainstream media which never tired of talking about it. The common man always knew that Manmohan Singh was the mask. The mask behind which hid the ugly face of the Congress party and its leader Sonia Gandhi.

Prime Minister Manmohan Singh

Prime Minister Manmohan Singh

Parkala Observer: Shrikant N Shenoy“It is natural. It is normal. Just leave it at that.”

That’s what the Congress party-led UPA government had to say over the fresh controversy arising out of the CBI director’s affidavit to the Supreme Court and Additional Solicitor General Harin Raval’s subsequent letter accusing Attorney General G E Vahanvati of trying to interfere in CBI’s probe report on coal scam.

The words used in para one has been the government’s stock reply in questions over various scams, or at least some variations of it.

Haughty, arrogant ministers have even tried to convince the people that there was no scam at all. Remember Kapil Sibal’s “zero loss” Theory.

With the developments of the past week, every single act of this government led by Prime Minister Manmohan Singh over the past few years over gargantuan scams that erupted one after the other has reiterated the serious doubts over his integrity.

So far the only left with the government and the Congress party was Manmohan Singh’s “personal honesty and integrity”.

But now this mask has fallen, as R Jagannathan puts it succintly in Firstpost. (Read here)

Write Jagannathan, the question to ask is why did so many government officials have to lie: to save the reputation of the government and its “honest” Prime Minister?”

“The tragedy is that so many people are being forced to utter falsehoods in this quest to protect the reputation of the government (already in tatters) and its head.

“Sorry, Dr Singh, this time it is different. We can’t give you the benefit of doubt, adds Jagannathan.

But tales of Singh’s personal honesty and integrity were always in the domain of the Congress party and the mainstream media which never tired of talking about it.

The common man always knew that Manmohan Singh was the mask. The mask behind which hid the ugly face of the Congress party and its leader Sonia Gandhi.

As far as this author is concerned, I have always held the belief that Manmohan Singh was a dishonest man. If he was held to that high pedestal of honesty, would he have in the first place file a false affidavit about Assam being his natural residence?

Once you have lied on oath, that veener of integrity has gone. I never understood why the media always thought that Singh was, as some still describe, “personally honest”.

A man who is not honest to his conscience, can never be truthful to anyone, forget even his maker.

And this “personally honest” man has presided over some of India’s worst scams since independence involving mind-boggling figures.

When he comes asking for votes in Karnataka — or even in other fora — his honesty is never reflected in his delivery. For one, a honest man would not read out speeches written by someone else.

He could have spoken from his heart, if he was indded talking the truth.

In all the scams, they have always tried to find scapegoats. Suresh Kalmadi was easily sacrificed because he was not a vote-getter. Sheila Dikshit was also named in the CWG scam, but nothing happened to her.

After J Jayalalithaa swept to power in Tamil Nadu, the DMK became expendable. So A Raja, Kanimozhi had to spend time behind bars.

At every stage in the 2G scam, every effort was made to shield the prime minister and his finance minister, though they were as deeply involved as Raja.

The Congress party and its legion of admirers and supporters in the media made sure that no Congress minister or any of his relative were even mentioned in any way. Take the Saradha chit fund scam. The media claim to have got the Saradha chief’s confessional letter in which even the wife of P Chidambaram was mentioned, but they did not utter her name and went hammer and tongs after the Trinamool Congress and its leader Mamata Banerjee.

Because Mamata Banerjee had dared to leave the Congress party-led UPA government. She went so far as to heap humiliation on Congress party supremo Sonia Gandhi.
For everything, Mamata had been the proverbial punching bag for the media for her unpardonable, nay, criminal act of deserting the UPA and shaking it to its very foundations.

But Nalini Chidambaram was not mentioned at all — at least on the English channels that I surf.

If it was BJP’s Meenakshi Lekhi instead of Nalini, would the media have engaged in a conspiracy of silence?

But coming back to Manmohan Singh, he is the biggest deception played on an unsuspecting nation by the Congress party.

That he knowingly and willingly allowed himself to be used, assuming this is correct, tells you volumes about this man and his “personal honesty and integrity”.

Manmohan Singh has been described by critics as spineless and shameless.

So it is no use demanding his resignation. It is quite obvious, he is answerable and grateful only to Madam Sonia Gandhi and the Congress party for giving him the most important chair in India.

It is we who are shameless for having the misfortune of not being able to convey to the people of India that Manmohan Singh is the “choron ka Sardar” (the boss of crooks). “Theek Hai?”


Leave a comment

Filed under Politics

Shame on you, Katju

Press Council of India Chairman retired Justice Markandey Katju tonight appealed to Maharashtra Governor K Sankarnarayanan to pardon actor Sanjay Dutt, who was sentenced to five years in an arms case related to the 1993 serial Bombay blasts.

Markandey Katju's photo as published on his blog

Markandey Katju’s photo as published on his blog

A former judge of the Supreme Court — which today brought about a near-closure to the worst terror attack faced by India and made the nation hold her head high — today has sought pardon for one of the convicts, saying the latter had “suffered a lot during the last 20 years”.

TV channels CNN-IBN and NDTV quoted a news agency report which said Press Council of India Chairman retired Justice Markandey Katju appealed to Maharashtra Governor K Sankarnarayanan to pardon actor Sanjay Dutt, who was sentenced to five years in an arms case related to the 1993 serial Bombay blasts.

Reactions poured in fast and furious on the social media condemning Katju with one word echoing strongly: “Shame”.

It was unbelievably amazing to see a former judge seeking pardon for a person whose conviction had just been upheld by India’s apes court, of which he was part of once. This come even as Bollywood starting tempering down its earlier reaction in full support of convict-actor Sanjay Dutt. While producer-director Mahesh Bhatt in the afternoon was “shocked” for the poor Sanjay Dutt, in the evening he tended to see this as justice being done.

Katju has been shooting from his mouth of late and has been facing criticism for using his position as PCI chairman for making wild and fanciful comments, with his widely-condemned negative article in The Hindu newsapaper on Gujarat Chief Minister as an example of his indiscretions.

A few of the tweets on Katju's statement.

A few of the tweets on Katju’s statement.

Social media also saw through the alleged blatant slant in favour of Sanjay Dutt across the channels which showed him as a victim rather than a criminal who was found guilty under India’s criminal justice system.

In talk later tonight, it was revealed that all sorts of tricks were used to try and get Sanjay discharged from the cases.

Earlier, Sanjay Dutt — notorious for his alleged links with Mumbai’s underworld — was booked under the stringent Terrorist and Disruptive Activities (Prevention) Act, which would have seen the actor going into jail for a longer period, but a trial court decided that he should be tried under the Arms Act. He was later convicted and jailed for a term of six years, which the Supreme Court, hearing the appeals, today reduced it to five years.

Sanjay Dutt has already been in jail for about 18 months and will have to spend the rest of the time in Pune’s Yerawada jail. He has up to four weeks to surrender and go to prison or pursue further legal remedies.

Former Mumbai police commissioner M N Singh CNN-IBN that Sanjay’s father, the late former MP Sunil Dutt of the Congress party, approach him several times to get his son off the hook. The police were under severe pressure from politicians to favour Sanjay Dutt.

Sunil Dutt, himself a Bollywood veteran and a powerful Congress politician, had also approached the late Shiv Sena supremo Bal Thackeray when the Sena-BJP was in government in Maharashtra to seek his “blessings” for Sanjay.

The CBI, which had taken over the case, did not go in for an appeal when the lower court decided to discharge the troubled actor from TADA charges, a move which raised many eyebrows.

The outpouring of support then and now for Sanjay, with media highlighting that more than Rs 300-400 crore would go down the drain after he goes to jail, showed the influence he enjoyed in showbiz and the media, especially the news channels.

The CBI was obviously used as a political tool to go soft on Sanjay Dutt. That India’s premier investigative agency was being manipulated shamefacedly by the Congress party-led government came in for ample amplification in the case of DMK leader M K Stalin’s case.

The DMK, an UPA ally, which had only two days back withdrawn support  to the  federal UPA government, found that its crown prince’s house was raided in Chennai by CBI officials for an apparent customs’ duty evasion case at the crack of dawn. The raid was called off a couple of hours later after a chorus of protests of innocence and anger by leading lights of the Congress party and government, including its chief Sonia Gandhi, Prime Minister Manmohan Singh and Finance Minister P Chidambaram (read here).

Coming back to Katju, the former judge pleaded for Sanjay Dutt raising the following points (read his letter to the Maharashtra governor published on NDTV here):


  • The event happen in 1993 i.e. 20 years ago. During this period Sanjay suffered a lot, and had a cloud hovering over his head throughout. He had to undergo various tribulations and indignities during this period. He had to go to Court often, he had to take the permission of the Court for foreign shootings, he could not get bank loans, etc.
  • Sanjay Dutt has already undergone 18 months in jail.
  • Sanjay Dutt has got married, and they have two small children.
  • He has not been held to be a terrorist, and had no hand in the bomb blasts.
  • His parents Sunil Dutt and Nargis worked for the good of society and the nation. Sunil Dutt and Nargis often went to border areas to give moral support to our brave jawans and did other social work for society.
  • Sanjay in this period of 20 years has through his film revived the memory of Mahatma Gandhi and the message of Gandhiji, the father of the nation.


Katju’s reasons for seeking pardon for Sanjay Duut is not only laughable, but seriously shameful.

What Katju omitted is that Sanjay has been a delinquent through his early years, having been a drug addict with involvement in petty cases, most of them brushed under the carpet due to his family links with the Congress party. He was arrested in 1982 for being in possession of drugs and was in prison for five years.

The now 53-year-old Sanjay also led a troubled life during his adulthood as well: The actor was cosy with the underworld mafia with reported links right up to internationally-designated terrorist Dawood Ibrahim, a former don of the Mumbai underworld.

His also led a controversial personal life. His first marriage ended in a disaster with his wife actress Richa Sharma dying of brain tumour.

He then married model, Rhea Pillai, which ended in a divorce after a short time. Later, he married another woman, Manyata aka Dilnawaz Sheikh aka Sara Khan, in a private ceremony in Goa after dating her for two years. Manyata was reputedly married more than once and that too persons with allegedly shady reputations. Her marriage with Sanjay was also controversial as it was reportedly illegal because she had not divorced her husband then.

All in all, Sanjay was not an ideal citizen as Katju wants the people to believe.

“Sanjay suffered a lot in the last 20 years,” Katju says. Dear Katju, he continued to act in films and raked in a hell of a lot of money, got involved in affairs and then married and had two children. Is this suffering?

In Modi’s case, Katju called him a Hitler and refuses to believe that he was not involved in the 2002 riots, despite not a single conviction, but goes all out to seek pardon for convict Sanjay Dutt, a man whose reputation has always cast a shadow throughout his life.

If Katju’s logic is to be applied, then all convicts in terror and other serious criminals can be safely sent home. And what about the victims? Let them go to hell?

As a judge, Katju was admired for his fearlessness, outspokenness and his crusading spirit.

After he retired, it was a swift fall from a high pedestal. Markandey Katju, shame on you!

Leave a comment

Filed under Politics